Football All Americans (by year)
| Name | Year | Team |
| Horr, Marquis F. (Bill) | 1908 | First |
| Schlacter, Christopher P. | 1915 | First |
| White, Harold A. | 1915 | First |
| Cobb, Alfred R. | 1917 | First |
| Alexander, J.A. (Joe) | 1918-19-20 | First |
| Usher, Louis C. | 1918 | First |
| Gulick, Bertrand | 1920 | First |
| MacRae, Edander G. (Pete) | 1923 | First |
| Hanson, Victor | 1926 | First |
| Steen, James | 1934 | First |
| Fleck, Robert R. | 1952-53 | First |
| Brown, James N. | 1956 | First |
| Luciano, Ronald M. | 1958 | First |
| Davis, Roger W. | 1959 | First |
| Mautino, Fred J. | 1959 | First |
| Yates, Robert E. | 1959 | First |
| Davis, Ernest R. | 1960-61 | First |
| Killorin, Patrick M. | 1964-65 | First |
| Little, Floyd D. | 1964, 1965, 1966 | First |
| Brown, Charles E. | 1965 | First |
| Bugenhagen, Gary A. | 1966 | First |
| Csonka, Lawrence R. | 1966-67 | First |
| Kyasky, Anthony J. | 1968 | First |
| Ehrmann, Joseph C. | 1970 | First |
| Myers, Thomas P. | 1971 | First |
| Preston, Raymond N. | 1975 | First |
| Monk, J. Arthur | 1979 | First |
| Anderson, Gary | 1981 | First |
| Charles, Michael | 1982 | First |
| Green, Timothy J. | 1984-85 | First |
| Gregory, Theodore | 1987 | First |
| McPherson, Donald R. | 1987 | First |
| Paul, Markus D. | 1988 | First |
| Flannery, John | 1990 | First |
| Ismail, Qadry R. | 1991 | First |
| Gedney, Christopher J. | 1992 | First |
| Harrison, Marvin D. | 1995 | First |
| Abrams, Kevin R. | 1995-96 | First |
| Darius, Donovin L. | 1997 | First |
| Johnson, Kevin L. | 1998 | First |
| Freeney, Dwight | 2001 | First |
