Blue-Gray
| 1942 | Dick Weber |
| 1945 | Bob Ferri |
| 1947 | Edward Dolan |
| Gene Scmidt | |
| 1953 | Les McClelland |
| Bob Leberman | |
| 1955 | Ed Albright |
| 1960 | Al Bemiller |
| 1961 | Dick Fiedler |
| Bob Stem | |
| Dave Sarrette | |
| Dick Easterly** | |
| 1963 | Bill Schoonover## |
| Len Slaby | |
| 1965 | Howard McCard |
| 1967 | Jim Murphy |
| 1968 | Gerry Beach |
| Cliff Ensley | |
| 1969 | Don Dorr |
| Dave McCard | |
| 1971 | Doug Auld |
| Stan Walters | |
| 1972 | Marty Januszkiewicz |
| 1977 | Richard Rosen |
| 1979 | Bill Hurley* |
| Art Monk | |
| Craig Wolfley | |
| 1980 | Jim Collins (a) |
| 1981 | Joe Morris* |
| 1983 | Blaise Winter |
| 1984 | Jaime Covington (a) |
| 1985 | Don McAulay |
| 1987 | Jim Fox |
| Scott Schwedes | |
| 1994 | Ernie Brown |
| Marcus Lee | |
| Terry Richardson | |
| 1995 | Bryce Bevill |
| 2001 | Eric Downing |
| Morlon Greenwood# | |
| 2004 | Rich Scanlon# |
| Christain Ferrara | |
| Nick Romeo |
Ben Schwartzwalder was the Blue coach in 1960, 1961, 1968.
Paul Pasqualoni was the defensive coach for the Blue squad in 2001.
* voted game's outstanding player
** voted game's outstanding back
# voted game's outstanding defensive player
## voted game's outstanding defensive lineman
(a) invited but did not participate
