Men's Basketball All-Americans (by year)
| Name | Organization | Year | Team |
| Castle, Lewis | Helms Foundation | 1912,14 | First |
| Schwarzer, Joseph | Helms Foundation | 1918 | First |
| Marcus, Leon | Helms Foundation | 1919 | First |
| Hanson, Victor | Helms Foundation | 1925-26-27 | First |
| Gabor, Billy | Helms Foundation | 1946-47 | First |
| Kiley, John | Helms Foundation | 1951 | First |
| Cohen, Vincent | Helms Foundation | 1957 | First |
| Bing, Dave | Helms Foundation | 1965 | First |
| NEA | 1965 | Second | |
| Consensus All-American | 1966 | First | |
| Harper, Vaughn | UPI | 1967 | Honorable Mention |
| Hicker, George | UPI | 1967 | Honorable Mention |
| Dean, Rick | UPI | 1967 | Honorable Mention |
| Smith, Bill | Helms Foundation | 1971 | First |
| Kohls, Greg | Helms Foundation | 1972 | First |
| AP, UPI | 1972 | Honorable Mention | |
| Basketball News | 1972 | Fifth | |
| DuVal, Dennis | AP, UPI | 1973 | Honorable Mention |
| Basketball Weekly | 1974 | Third | |
| Sporting News, Universal Sports, Street & Smith, Citizen Saving Foundation | 1974 | First | |
| Hacket, Rudy | Basketball Weekly | 1975 | Third |
| AP | 1975 | Second | |
| Citizen Savings Foundation | 1975 | First | |
| Lee, Jim | Citizen Savings Foundation | 1975 | First |
| Bouie, Roosvelt | Basketball Weekly | 1977 | Freshman Second |
| AP | 1979 | Honorable Mention | |
| Citizen Savings Foundation | 1979 | First | |
| USBWA | 1980 | First | |
| Citizen Savings Foundation | 1980 | First | |
| Medalist | 1980 | First | |
| UPI, Basketball Weekly | 1980 | Third | |
| AP, Sporting News | 1980 | Honorable Mention | |
| Orr, Louis | AP, Sporting News | 1980 | Honorable Mention |
| Schayes, Dan | AP | 1981 | Honorable Mention |
| Santifer, Erich | AP, Sporting News | 1982 | Honorable Mention |
| Interstate Bank | 1983 | First | |
| AP | 1983 | Honorable Mention | |
| Rautins, Leo | AP, UPI | 1983 | Honorable Mention |
| Addison, Rafael | Basketball Weekly, Sporting News | 1984 | Honorable Mention |
| Basketball Times | 1985 | Third | |
| AP, UPI, Sporting News | 1985 | Honorable Mention | |
| Washington, Dwayne | Basketball Weekly | 1984 | Freshman First |
| AP, UPI, Basketball Weekly, Sporting News | 1984 | Honorable Mention | |
| USBWA, UPI, Basketball Weekly | 1985 | Second | |
| AP, NABC | 1985 | Third | |
| Sporting News | 1985 | Honorable Mention | |
| UPI, Basketball Weekly | 1986 | Second | |
| AP, NABC, Basketball Times | 1986 | Third | |
| Sporting News | 1986 | Honorable Mention | |
| Seikaly, Rony | Basketball Times | 1985 | Third |
| Sporting News | 1987 | Honorable Mention | |
| Wooden | 1988 | First | |
| USBWA, NABC, Basketball Weekly | 1988 | Second | |
| UPI | 1988 | Third | |
| AP, Sporting News | 1988 | Honorable Mention | |
| Alexis, Wendell | AP, Sporting News | 1986 | Honorable Mention |
| Coleman, Derrick | UPI, Basketball Weekly | 1987 | First |
| Sporting News | 1987 | Honorable Mention | |
| Sporting News | 1988 | Honorable Mention | |
| Basketball Times | 1989 | First | |
| UPI | 1989 | Second | |
| NABC, Basketball Weekly | 1989 | Third | |
| AP, Sporting News | 1989 | Honorable Mention | |
| Consensus All-American (AP, UPI, NABC, USBWA, Wooden, Naismith, Sporting News, Basketball Times, Basketball) Weekly | 1990 | ||
| Douglas, Sherman | AP, Sporting News | 1987 | Honorable Mention |
| UPI, Basketball Times | 1988 | Second | |
| AP | 1988 | Third | |
| Sporting News | 1988 | Honorable Mention | |
| AP, Wodden, Basketball Weekly | 1989 | First | |
| NABC | 1989 | Third | |
| UPI, Sporting News | 1989 | Honorable Mention | |
| Thompson, Stephen | AP, Sporting News | 1989 | Honorable Mention |
| AP, UPI, Sporting News | 1990 | Honorable Mention | |
| Owens, Billy | AP | 1989 | Freshman First |
| UPI, NABC | 1990 | Third | |
| AP, Sporting News | 1990 | Honorable Mention | |
| Consensus All-American (AP, UPI, NABC, USBWA, Wooden, Scripps, Howard) | 1991 | First | |
| Sporting News, Basketball Times, Basketball Weekly | 1991 | Second | |
| Autry, Adrian | Basketball Weekly | 1991 | Second |
| Moten, Lawrence | UPI, Basketball Times, Basketball Weekly | 1992 | First |
| AP | 1993 | Honorable Mention | |
| AP | 1994 | Honorable Mention | |
| Sporting News | 1995 | Second | |
| AP, NABC | 1995 | Third | |
| Wallace, John | Basketball Times, Basketball Weekly | 1993 | Second |
| USBWA, AP, College Sport, Basketball Times, The Sporting News | 1996 | Second | |
| Basketball Weekly | 1996 | Third | |
| Thomas, Etan | Wooden Award | 2000 | First |
| NABC | 2000 | Third | |
| Shumpert, Preston | AP | 2001 | Honorable Mention |
| AP | 2002 | Honorable Mention | |
| Anthony, Carmelo | Basketball Times | 2003 | Freshman First |
| AP | 2003 | Freshman Honorable Mention | |
| Conensus All-American, The Sporting News | 2003 | First | |
| AP, Basketball Times, ESPN.com, NABC, USBWA | 2003 | Second | |
| Warrick, Hakim | ESPN.com, The Sporting News | 2004 | Second |
| AP, NABC | 2004 | Third | |
|
Consensus All-American, AP, CollegeInsider.com, NABC, Rivals.com, Rupp Award, Senior Class Award, Wooden Award |
2005 | First | |
| The Sporting News, Sports Illustrated, USBWA | 2005 | Second | |
| Basketball Times | 2005 | Third | |
| McNamara, Gerry | AP | 2006 | Honorable Mention |
| Nichols, Demetris | AP | 2007 | Honorable Mention |
